US investors, please take note: Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs are now more efficient

There’s good news for the US crypto industry. A major change has just made crypto ETFs even more flexible and efficient. Last week, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) approved something called "in-kind creation and redemption" for crypto exchange-traded funds (ETFs), including those that track Bitcoin and Ethereum.

What does that mean in simple terms?

Before this change, getting in or out of a crypto ETF required using cash. Now, authorized participants, or APs (typically large financial institutions), can exchange in-kind, meaning actual Bitcoin or Ethereum directly for ETF shares, and vice versa, without involving cash. This is a significant development because it streamlines the process, making it smoother, faster, and more tax-efficient to move in and out of these investment products.

First, understand what creations and redemptions are

‍

The creation and redemption mechanism of ETFs enables the continuous issuance and redemption of ETF shares, thereby maintaining their market efficiency. Large financial firms, called authorized participants (APs), help make this happen. They work with the ETF issuer to adjust the number of shares so that the ETF’s price stays close to the actual value of what it holds. 

ETF creations and redemptions can be executed in two primary ways: in-kind or cash transactions. 

Let’s break it down:

• Creation (making new ETF shares): When demand for an ETF increases, authorized participants can create new ETF shares. They send either cash or the actual underlying asset (like stocks or Bitcoin) to the ETF issuer. In return, they get a basket of new ETF shares, which they can sell to other investors. This helps increase supply and keeps the ETF price stable.

What will happen after the SEC’s approval? Instead of paying cash, a firm can give real Bitcoin or Ethereum to the ETF provider and get ETF shares in return.

• Redemption (removing ETF shares): When there's too much supply or not enough demand, authorized participants can redeem (or cash out) ETF shares. They return ETF shares to the issuer. In exchange, they get either cash or the underlying asset.

What will happen after the SEC’s approval? To exit, a firm can return the ETF shares and get back the same amount in crypto like Bitcoin or Ethereum, not cash.

How the SEC’s in-kind approval helps the crypto market

The SEC’s decision to allow in-kind creation and redemption for crypto ETFs is a major step forward for the industry. It will: 

• Lower trading costs: Swapping real crypto instead of using cash avoids extra fees.
• Better price tracking: ETF prices can stay more closely aligned with the actual price of Bitcoin or Ethereum.
• Improved efficiency: Especially useful for large institutions and long-term investors.
• Tax benefits: In-kind transactions can reduce taxable events at the fund level, though investors should always check with a tax advisor.
  
  

In short, it’s a big win for both investors and the broader crypto market.