How a physically backed bitcoin ETP works, from order to custody
Back

A physically backed bitcoin exchange-traded product (ETP) rests on a chain of counterparties, each with one defined job, between the order screen and the asset itself. A committee evaluating any bitcoin ETP is approving that chain, not a ticker.

A bitcoin ETP order settles in a brokerage account, not on a crypto exchange

A bitcoin ETP order never reaches a crypto exchange. It follows the same route as an order for any listed security.

The broker routes the order to the exchange where the ETP is listed, using the same infrastructure that handles orders for an Apple share or an S&P 500 index fund. A market maker, a specialized trading firm that quotes prices so orders fill quickly and cheaply, takes the other side of the trade if no seller is available. The position then settles in the investor’s brokerage account.

This is the secondary market, where existing ETP units change hands. Because it only moves existing units, a separate mechanism must supply new ones.

Authorized participants create new units and anchor the ETP price to bitcoin

New ETP units are created by an authorized participant (AP), a large financial institution with a formal agreement with the issuer.

When demand outstrips supply, the AP delivers cash or bitcoin to the issuer. The issuer creates new units and returns them to the AP, who releases them into the market. Equity, bond and gold exchange-traded funds have used the same creation and redemption process for decades. Only the underlying asset differs.

The same mechanism addresses pricing. If the ETP trades above the value of its bitcoin, an AP can create units and increase supply. If it trades below, an AP can redeem units and reduce supply. This arbitrage is the process designed to keep the ETP price close to the price of bitcoin.

Physical backing means the product buys real bitcoin and an independent custodian holds it

Physically backed means the product holds actual bitcoin, not a derivative that tracks its price. When an AP triggers a creation, bitcoin is purchased in the open market through regulated institutional trading venues, sized to match the new units.

That bitcoin then moves to a custodian, a company independent of the issuer whose sole function is safekeeping. The custodian is selected for its security infrastructure: cold storage (bitcoin held on hardware never connected to the internet), multi-signature controls (several independent approvals required before any bitcoin can move), insurance coverage and regular third-party audits. 

The bitcoin is also held on a segregated basis, ring-fenced from the issuer’s own assets and from the assets of every other product. The structure is designed so that, if the issuer failed, the bitcoin would sit outside the issuer’s estate and remain held for ETP holders.

The structure removes operational complexity, not market risk

A bitcoin ETP does not protect investors from bitcoin’s price movements. Bitcoin has experienced drawdowns exceeding 50% at multiple points in its history, and holding it through an ETP does not change that.

The ETP structure changes how bitcoin is accessed, through exchange infrastructure and safeguards that institutional investors already know. It does not change the asset. Bitcoin remains a new asset class with real volatility, an evolving regulatory environment and open questions about its long-run role in a portfolio.

Whether a bitcoin ETP belongs in a portfolio is a question for each committee to answer. The next step is to map each counterparty in this chain to the prospectus and custody documentation before the allocation discussion begins. Watch how a physically backed bitcoin ETP works, step by step, in the video.

‍

FAQ

Is a bitcoin ETP backed by real bitcoin? 

A physically backed bitcoin ETP holds actual bitcoin, not a derivative that tracks its price. When an authorized participant triggers the creation of new units, bitcoin is purchased in the open market and moved to an independent custodian. Each unit represents a share of that bitcoin.

Do I need a crypto exchange account to buy a bitcoin ETP? 

No. A bitcoin ETP is bought through a standard brokerage account, on the exchange where it is listed, in the same way as any other listed security. The order never reaches a crypto exchange.

Where is the bitcoin in a bitcoin ETP stored? 

It is held by a custodian that is independent of the issuer. The custodian uses cold storage, meaning hardware never connected to the internet, along with multi-signature controls, insurance coverage and third-party audits. The bitcoin is held on a segregated basis, separate from the issuer’s own assets.

What happens to the bitcoin in an ETP if the issuer fails? 

The structure is designed to hold bitcoin on a segregated basis with an independent custodian, outside the issuer’s own assets, for the benefit of ETP holders. Investors should confirm the specific insolvency treatment in the product prospectus.

Does a bitcoin ETP reduce bitcoin’s price risk? 

No. The ETP changes how bitcoin is accessed, not how it behaves. Bitcoin has experienced drawdowns exceeding 50% at multiple points in its history, and the same exposure applies through an ETP.

Table of contents

Share

This report has been prepared and issued by 21Shares AG for publication globally. All information used in the publication of this report has been compiled from publicly available sources that are believed to be reliable, however we do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of this report. Crypto asset trading involves a high degree of risk. The crypto asset market is new to many and unproven and may have the potential to not grow as expected.

Currently, there is relatively small use of crypto assets in the retail and commercial marketplace in comparison to relatively large use by speculators, thus contributing to price volatility that could adversely affect an investment in crypto assets. In order to participate in the trading of crypto assets, you should be capable of evaluating the merits and risks of the investment and be able to bear the economic risk of losing your entire investment.

Nothing in this publication does or should be considered as an offer by 21Shares AG and/or its affiliates to sell or solicitation by 21Shares AG or its parent of any offer to buy bitcoin or other crypto assets or derivatives. This report is provided for information and research purposes only and should not be construed or presented as an offer or solicitation for any investment. The information provided does not constitute a prospectus or any offering and does not contain or constitute an offer to sell or solicit an offer to invest in any jurisdiction.

Readers are cautioned that any such forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve risks and uncertainties, and that actual results may differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements as a result of various factors. The information contained herein may not be considered as economic, legal, tax, or other advice and users are cautioned against basing investment decisions or other decisions solely on the content hereof.

Nos dernières analyses

Tenez-vous informé grâce à notre newsletter hebdomadaire et approfondissez vos connaissances grâce aux revues mensuelles.

Voir toute la recherche
Article page link
Two stacked magazines titled 'Managing Digital Assets in Client Portfolios' with mountain and chess images on the cover.
Bitcoin
Article page link
Markets and Macro
Article page link

Adrian Fritz

Stratège en chef des investissements

Adrian Fritz est le stratège en chef des investissements chez 21shares, où il définit les perspectives du marché mondial de l'entreprise et communique ses stratégies d'investissement dans le domaine des actifs numériques. Il assure la liaison entre la recherche, les produits, les marchés financiers et les ventes afin d'aider les investisseurs à naviguer dans le paysage en constante évolution des actifs numériques. Il est également chargé de cours à la HWZ Zurich University of Applied Sciences et expert certifié en crypto-finance (CCFE). Avant de rejoindre l'industrie des cryptomonnaies, il a travaillé pendant plusieurs années dans la finance traditionnelle, notamment dans le conseil en gestion, la finance d'entreprise et la banque d'investissement.

See all articles